Full Court upholds personal compensation orders against directors for oppressive share issues
The development
The Full Federal Court dismissed an appeal by directors against findings that share issues were oppressive under s 232(e) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). In Aulich v Scott, delivered on 30 October 2026, the Court upheld orders under s 233 requiring the directors personally to compensate the affected shareholder. The compensation was equivalent to the value of her shareholding at the time of dilution.
The shareholder had wanted to be bought out at fair value. The directors instead issued shares that reduced her interests in the companies to a negligible amount. The appeal challenged the primary judge’s findings that the share issues were undertaken for an improper purpose and without commercial rationale. The Full Court found no error in the finding that the share issues were oppressive.
The directors also challenged the relief. One company was in liquidation and the other was likely to enter administration for reasons unrelated to the oppressive conduct. The appeal raised whether relief remained appropriate where oppression had ceased because of external administration. The Full Court found no error in the exercise of the discretion to require personal compensation from the directors, leaving those orders in place.
The briefing
- Regulator or source
- Federal Court
- Type
- Case · Court decisions
- Subject matter
- Commercial, corporate & consumer
- Jurisdiction
- Cth
- Published
- 30 October 2026
- Submissions close
- No deadline
- Reference
- Aulich v Scott [2026] FCAFC 139
- Priority
- Watch
What it means for business
For companies considering share issues while a shareholder seeks an exit, the judgment provides a reason to examine the commercial rationale, purpose and dilution effect together. Board papers, capital-raising approvals and shareholder communications could usefully record those matters. A review of shareholder agreements and constitutional provisions dealing with share issues and exit arrangements may also help identify governance risks before a proposed issue proceeds.
The personal compensation orders warrant attention in board-level risk assessments. In this case, the companies’ financial circumstances and the cessation of oppression through external administration did not displace the orders against the directors.
Entry last reviewed 19 November 2026.
What does this mean for your business?
If this development touches your contracts, compliance or reporting, it may be worth a short conversation. Get in touch through our contact page and a senior lawyer will reply within one business day.
Request a fixed-fee scopeMore in Commercial, corporate & consumer
18 November 2026 · Court decisions · Federal Court
Federal Court dismisses misleading conduct claim over proposed Port Botany lease
17 November 2026 · Court decisions · Federal Court
Davis v Wilson: appeal dismissed over sandalwood valuations and financial reporting representations
13 November 2026 · Media releases · ACCC
ACCC names eight product groups for supermarket excessive pricing monitoring
5 November 2026 · Enforcement · ACCC
ACCC directs Armaguard to maintain cash distribution services until 30 June 2027
More from Federal Court
18 November 2026 · Court decisions · Federal Court
Federal Court dismisses misleading conduct claim over proposed Port Botany lease
17 November 2026 · Court decisions · Federal Court
Davis v Wilson: appeal dismissed over sandalwood valuations and financial reporting representations
16 November 2026 · Court decisions · Federal Court
Full Court dismisses appeal concerning call-centre incentives and conflicted remuneration
16 November 2026 · Court decisions · Federal Court
ASIC v Diamond Wheels: corporate penalties determined at $2.5 million and $3.5 million
Regulatory alerts
Get the radar in your inbox.
A short email when something worth knowing lands. Pick the areas you care about and skip the rest.
This register contains general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Envision Legal accepts no liability for any loss arising from reliance on this content. You should seek independent legal advice tailored to your specific circumstances. For enquiries, contact Envision Legal.
